Ohtani Signs With L.A. Dodgers for $700 Million For 10 Years
Print Friendly and PDF

Nominally, that $700 million is the biggest contract in the history of sports, bigger even that Lionel Messi’s with Barcelona in 2017. It’s not really $70 million per season, though, because more than half of the payments will be deferred until some point in the future. But no details have been released yet, so you can’t yet calculate the net present value of the deal.

Over the last three seasons, Japan’s unique pitcher-slugger has been worth 28.5 wins above a replacement-quality player (i.e., a fill-in player that could be readily obtained from the minor leagues or from another team). Half is from his value as a starting pitcher, half from his slugging as a designated hitter.

That’s a huge figure for modern baseball outside of the steroid level. For example, from 1990-1992, a pre-PED Barry Bonds in his prime was worth 26.7 and in the same years, Roger Clements was worth 27.0.

I don’t think the following list includes all the examples of star players going back to the 1940s with a three year stretch of spectacular Wins Above Replacement, but it includes a lot of them. It show that Ohtani’s 2021-2023 run ranks among the legends.

Star Years WAR
Willie Mays 1963-1965 32.9
Barry Bonds PEDs 2001-2003 32.8
Mickey Mantle 1955-1957 32.6
Ted Williams 1941-1946 31.0
Bob Gibson 1968-1970 30.5
Wilbur Wood 1971-1973 30.0
Joe Morgan 1974-1976 29.2
Shohei Ohtani 2021-2023 28.5
Roger Clements PEDs 1996-1998 27.8
Mike Trout 2014-2016 27.8
Stan Musial 1948-1950 27.7
Randy Johnson 2007-2009 27.7
Albert Pujols 2007-2009 27.7
Alex Rodriguez 2000-2002 27.5
Ernie Banks 1958-1960 27.4
Robin Roberts 1952-1954 27.2
Hank Aaron 1961-1963 27.1
Roger Clemens pre-PEDs 1990-1992 27.0
Barry Bonds pre-PEDs 1991-1993 26.9
Mookie Betts 2016-2018 26.6
Phil Niekro 1977-1979 26.3
Jackie Robinson 1949-1951 26.3
Tom Seaver 1971-1973 26.0
Sandy Koufax 1963-1965 26.0
Cal Ripken 1989-1991 25.7
Mike Schmidt 1974-1976 25.5
Greg Maddux 1994-1996 25.4
Roberto Clemente 1966-1968 25.4
Wade Boggs 1985-1987 25.4
Ken Griffey Jr. 1996-1998 25.4
Ferguson Jenkins 1969-1971 24.6
Robin Yount 1982-1984 23.7
Curt Schilling 2001-2003 23.3
Clayton Kershaw 2013-2015 23.1
Max Scherzer 2016-2018 21.4
Aaron Judge 2021-2023 21.1
Jacob DeGrom 2017-2019 20.9
Pete Rose 1972-1974 20.2
Marcus Semien 2021-2023 20.2
Bryce Harper 2015-2017 16.1
Gerrit Cole 2021-2023 15.6

Baseball appears to be getting harder to dominate for three years in a row the way Ohtani has. If you go back to the beginning of the 20th Century, fireballer Walter Johnson had 40.0 WAR from 1912-1914 and Babe Ruth 34.1 from 1926-1928. In contrast, Bryce Harper is considered a superstar of the current game, but his best three year stretch only adds up to 16.1.

Probably the most forgotten name on the above list is knuckleballer Wilbur Woods who pitched an insane number of innings for the Chicago White Sox in the early 1970s.

In any case, it’s a risky deal for the Dodgers because it’s not clear if Shohei Ohtani will ever pitch again. He’ll take next year off from pitching due to surgery late last season. He apparently will be able to swing the bat in 2024. Last season he was the best hitter in the American League.

On the other hand, when not pitching, Ohtani has been playing designated hitter. And it’s not all that hard to get a lot of production out of the DH spot. For example, last season the Dodgers signed aged slugger J.D. Martinez to a one year deal for $10 million and got a ton of power out of him.

If Ohtani is washed up as a pitcher, he presumably can play left or right field and be a modest defensive asset on top of his bat, and let somebody less athletic DH.

Ohtani is 2.5 years younger than when Albert Pujols signed his disastrous 10-year-deal with the California Angels in 2012.

The Dodgers, a very smart franchise, presumably have theories for how they will pay Ohtani’s huge contract. Presumably, they figure on extracting revenue from Japanese in Japan in various ways.

The Los Angeles Dodgers made a fortune off of Mexican pitcher Fernando Valenzuela by making the Dodgers even more popular with Mexican-Americans in Southern California than they had already been. Before that, Sandy Koufax had gladdened Southern California’s large Jewish population.

The Japanese-American population isn’t that big, but perhaps the Dodgers think Ohtani will galvanize the Asian-American population in general, both in SoCal and nationally.

On the other hand, Ohtani doesn’t speak much English, is a private person who doesn’t go out much (I recall a news story that Ohtani going out to a restaurant during the mid-season All Star break was the first time he’d set foot in a restaurant since spring training), and cultivates a pleasantly boring image. The most famous thing about him off the field is that during the off-season he works out six hours per day and sleeps 12 hours per day.

All in all, I expect a ticket to Dodger Stadium will be even less affordable than it already is.

[Comment at Unz.com]

Print Friendly and PDF